By David Finegold and Ben Marshall
Expectations of Fellows. All NBFPs require Fellows to sit on a nonprofit board, usually in a non-voting capacity, and almost all also provide Fellows with the opportunity to serve on a subcommittee. Additionally, slightly over half of NBFPs require that Fellows complete a pro bono consulting project as part of their service (in most of the remainder, projects are strongly recommended and carried out by 50-80% of Fellows). “What’s surprising is how engaged and dynamic students have been,” observed Karyn Kirk, the Chief Legal Officer of YMCA, a long-time NBFP partner organization. “We've had phenomenal Board Fellows for as long as I've been doing this. And if possible, every year they’re just better and better.”
NBFP Size and Duration. NBFPs vary widely in how many Board Fellows they support and how long their programs last. The largest individual cohort is the Board Fellows Program at Chicago Booth, which selects an average of 80 Fellows a year to serve for 7 months. The largest overall program, however, is Northwestern Kellogg, which selects 50 Board Fellows from each first-year MBA class to serve an 18-month term and recently expanded to include 5-10 Board Scholars from the part-time MBAi program serving for one term (meaning that at peak times there may be 110 total participants). Most programs are significantly smaller. Excluding these two NBFPs, the average cohort size is 35 Fellows, and the smallest selects just 6-10 Fellows per cohort.
Curriculum Design. In his book How to Lead Nonprofits, Nick Grono argues that nonprofit leadership skills can be taught, just not in the same way as they are taught to future for-profit leaders. One way NBFPs make sure students are better prepared to work in the nonprofit sector is by pairing experiential and classroom learning. Some NBFPs include no formal education, but most offer either optional governance or nonprofit management classes, or mandatory but non-credit-bearing options like faculty-led lunch-and-learns, half-day training sessions, and mentoring.
Two schools (Northwestern Kellogg and Washington Olin) offer required for-credit classes specifically designed for Fellows. These teach governance, including the purpose of a board, the roles and responsibilities of board members, and what good behavior looks like (from board prep to integrating operational and strategic priorities). They also cover specific content areas, like how to read a Form 990. Additionally, classes allow students to share their fellowship experiences, and to role-play situations they may face on a board (e.g., “How should we handle an executive director who is underperforming or what happens if a board must consider shutting down the organization?”).
The learnings from this coursework can be of value long after the Fellowships are over. Sarah Buhayer completed the Kellogg Board Fellows program and now serves as Director of Strategy Office for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation as well as chairing the Board of the Seattle Science Museum. “I graduated from business school in 2011 and have moved a lot since then, [getting] rid of a lot of books and papers… One of the few binders I’ve saved is for Board Fellows. I still go back to it and find those reference materials to be hugely helpful: either for me or for sharing with colleagues, mentees, and others.”
Level of Institutional Support. The size, duration, and teaching expectations of NBFPs are both causes and consequences of the amount of investment made by individual schools. In all cases, students play important roles in recruiting, organizing educational and/or social activities, and serving as ambassadors and coordinators. But the range of school involvement varies greatly.
At one end of the spectrum are schools like Yale School of Management, where students lead the entire program, including nonprofit relationship management and program design. In the middle are programs with some staff involvement—typically a director with the support of one or two program managers—often nestled in a school’s center of government or social impact, or in some cases (e.g., at NYU Stern and Washington Foster) in the team responsible for student and/or community engagement or experiential learning. In the largest programs there is typically a staff member who devotes a significant portion of their time to recruiting and maintaining relationships with nonprofit partners and providing guidance and oversight of the program, as well as a faculty advisor who oversees the educational content and can serve as a mentor to students.